Differences Between a Holding Company and an Operating Company
When structuring a business, entrepreneurs in the UK often face a strategic decision: whether to operate under a holding company, an operating company, or a combination of both. Each type of entity serves distinct purposes, carries different risks, and offers unique benefits. Understanding the differences between them is crucial for tax efficiency, liability protection, and long-term growth.
This post explores holding company vs operating company, covering definitions, benefits, risks, tax considerations, examples, and best practices to help you decide which structure suits your business goals.
What is a Holding Company?
A holding company is a parent business entity that primarily exists to own and control shares in other companies, rather than engaging directly in trade or services. Its main function is strategic oversight and asset management.
Key features of a holding company:
- Owns shares in one or more subsidiaries.
- Protects valuable assets (e.g., property, intellectual property, or investments).
- Does not usually sell goods or services directly.
- Generates income from dividends, rents, royalties, or management fees.
- Provides a layer of protection by separating operating risks from assets.
UK Example: Many large corporations like Unilever PLC or Diageo PLC use holding company structures to oversee multiple subsidiaries across industries and jurisdictions.
What is an Operating Company?
An operating company is the business that engages in the day-to-day commercial activities—selling products, delivering services, hiring employees, and dealing directly with customers.
Key features of an operating company:
- Handles daily operations and trading.
- Employs staff, manages suppliers, and interacts with customers.
- Bears the commercial risks of running a business.
- May be owned wholly or partly by a holding company.
- Subject to corporation tax on trading profits.
UK Example: A local restaurant chain trading under a limited company would be considered an operating company, as it conducts direct business with customers.
Holding Company vs Operating Company: Key Differences
| Feature | Holding Company | Operating Company |
| Purpose | To own assets, subsidiaries, and provide oversight | To trade, provide services, and generate operational revenue |
| Activities | Asset management, investment, strategic control | Day-to-day operations, customer transactions |
| Risk Exposure | Lower – insulated from trading risks | Higher – directly exposed to liabilities and operational risks |
| Revenue Sources | Dividends, royalties, interest, rental income | Sales, service income, contracts |
| Tax Treatment | May benefit from tax reliefs on dividends and disposals | Pays corporation tax on trading profits |
| Liabilities | Generally limited to investments in subsidiaries | Full exposure to operational liabilities (e.g., lawsuits, debts) |
| Use Case | Protecting assets, expansion, and corporate structuring | Running and managing the actual business |
Why Use a Holding Company?
Entrepreneurs and investors often establish holding companies for strategic reasons, such as:
- Asset Protection
- Valuable assets (property, IP, cash reserves) are kept in the holding company, shielding them from trading risks.
- Tax Efficiency
- In the UK, dividends received from subsidiaries are often exempt from corporation tax.
- Share disposals may qualify for Substantial Shareholdings Exemption (SSE), reducing capital gains tax liability.
- Expansion and Flexibility
- Easier to acquire or sell subsidiaries without disturbing other parts of the business.
- Succession Planning
- Shares in a holding company can be more easily transferred to heirs or investors, simplifying generational planning.
Risks and Challenges of Holding Companies
While they offer benefits, holding companies also have potential downsides:
- Administrative Complexity: Requires additional accounting, filings, and governance.
- Increased Costs: More companies mean more legal and compliance costs.
- Tax Traps: Misuse of intercompany loans or transfer pricing can attract HMRC scrutiny.
- Not Always Necessary: Smaller businesses may not need the complexity of a holding structure.
Advantages of an Operating Company
Operating companies are the foundation of most businesses, and they provide benefits such as:
- Direct Revenue Generation: Engage with customers to generate income.
- Simple Structure: Easier and cheaper to run compared to layered corporate groups.
- Entrepreneurial Agility: Perfect for startups and SMEs testing a business idea.
Make Filing Your Confirmation Statement Simple
